ninkilim.com/29
408 days ago, still valid: https://x.com/R34lB0rg/status/1718049570498715701
هناك بالفعل تشابهات بين كيفية تجاهل أو شك في القصص من معسكرات الاعتقال النازية في البداية وبين التجاهلات المشابهة للروايات في الصراعات الحديثة، خاصة في سياق مصطلح "Pallywood" الذي يستخدم لوصف الادعاءات بخصوص تلاعب وسائل الإعلام الفلسطينية:
نفي وتجاهل الفظائع:
ألمانيا النازية: خلال وبعد الحرب العالمية الثانية، كانت العديد من القصص التي حكاها الناجون من معسكرات الاعتقال تلتقي بالشكوك أو النفي المباشر. ادعى بعضهم أن هذه كانت مبالغات أو أكاذيب صريحة من قبل الحلفاء لأغراض الدعاية. نفي الهولوكوست، الذي يستمر حتى اليوم، يتضمن غالبًا تجاهل شهادات الناجين كأكاذيب أو مبالغات. الصراعات الحديثة: في الصراعات المعاصرة، خاصة التي تشمل إسرائيل وفلسطين، تم تصنيف بعض الروايات أو الأدلة البصرية لعذاب الفلسطينيين على أنها "Pallywood"، مشيرًا إلى أن هذه مصحوبة أو مرتبة لأغراض الدعاية. هذا يعكس تجاهل قصص معسكرات الاعتقال من خلال تقترح أن العذاب المعروض ليس حقيقيًا بل مغلوب عليه للمكسب السياسي.
استخدام الدعاية والتضليل:
ألمانيا النازية: استخدم النازيون الدعاية بشكل واسع لإخفاء أفعالهم الإبادية، مقدمين أنفسهم كضحايا أو محررين بينما يتجاهلون التقارير عن فظائعهم كدعاية حلفائية. ادعاءات Pallywood: يتضمن مصطلح "Pallywood" حملة متعمدة لتلاعب وسائل الإعلام لأغراض سياسية، مشابهة لكيفية التي سعت بها الدعاية النازية لإعادة تشكيل الواقع.
التأثير على الرأي العام:
نفي الهولوكوست: من خلال تجاهل القصص كأكاذيب، يهدف مكابرو الهولوكوست إلى تغيير الذاكرة التاريخية والفهم العام، غالبًا بهدف تحسين صورة ألمانيا النازية أو خدمة أجندات سياسية أو أيديولوجية حالية. الصراعات الحالية: من خلال تسمية الأدلة على العذاب كـ"Pallywood"، هناك محاولة لتأثير على الرأي العالمي، مما قد يقلل من الضغط الدولي أو الدعم لإحدى الجهات من خلال إلقاء الشك على صحة الأحداث المبلغ عنها.
دور الاعلام والتكنولوجيا:
عصر الحرب العالمية الثانية: كانت نشر المعلومات أبطأ وأقل انتشارًا، ولكن حتى ذلك الحين، كانت هناك جهود للتشكيك أو تقليل قيمة التقارير من المعسكرات من خلال السيطرة على روايات وسائل الإعلام. العصر الحديث: مع ظهور وسائل التواصل الاجتماعي والأخبار الفورية، زادت القدرة على نشر وتكذيب هذه الروايات. ومع ذلك، سرعة وكمية المعلومات تتيح أيضًا نشر التضليل بسرعة، بما في ذلك ادعاءات تصميم الأحداث.
There are indeed parallels between how stories from Nazi concentration camps were initially dismissed or questioned and similar dismissals of narratives in modern conflicts, particularly in the context of the term "Pallywood" used to describe alleged Palestinian media manipulation:
Denial and Dismissal of Atrocities:
Nazi Germany: During and post-World War II, many stories from concentration camp survivors were met with skepticism or outright denial. Some claimed these were exaggerations or outright fabrications by the Allies for propaganda purposes. Holocaust denial, which persists to this day, often involves dismissing survivor testimonies as lies or exaggerations.
Modern Conflicts: In contemporary conflicts, particularly involving Israel and Palestine, some narratives or visual evidence of Palestinian suffering have been labeled as "Pallywood," suggesting that these are staged for propaganda. This mirrors the dismissal of concentration camp stories by suggesting that the suffering shown is not genuine but manipulated for political gain.
Use of Propaganda and Disinformation:
Nazi Germany: The Nazis used propaganda extensively to hide their genocidal actions, portraying themselves as victims or liberators while dismissing reports of their atrocities as Allied propaganda.
Pallywood Claims: Similarly, the term "Pallywood" implies a deliberate campaign to manipulate media for political purposes, akin to how Nazi propaganda sought to reshape reality.
Impact on Public Perception:
Holocaust Denial: By dismissing stories as lies, Holocaust deniers aimed to alter historical memory and public understanding, often with the goal of rehabilitating the image of Nazi Germany or to serve current political or ideological agendas.
Current Conflicts: By labeling evidence of suffering as "Pallywood," there's an attempt to influence global opinion, potentially reducing international pressure or support for one side by casting doubt on the authenticity of reported events.
The Role of Media and Technology:
World War II Era: The dissemination of information was slower and less widespread, but even then, there were efforts to discredit or downplay reports from the camps through control of media narratives.
Modern Era: With the advent of social media and instant news, the capacity for both spreading and debunking such narratives has increased. However, the speed and volume of information also allow for rapid dissemination of disinformation, including claims of staging events.
If it walks like a duck and quacks like a duck, then it probably is a duck.
Rhetoric and Intent: Some of the rhetoric from Israeli officials, especially during conflicts with Hamas, has been compared to Nazi dehumanization tactics. References to "Amalek" (a biblical enemy of Israel) by some Israeli leaders have been interpreted by critics as advocating for the total destruction of enemies, akin to Nazi ideology's dehumanization of Jews.
Impact on Civilians: The blockade of Gaza, the destruction in military operations, and the resultant humanitarian crises have led some to draw parallels to the conditions in ghettos during the Holocaust, where Jews were confined and subjected to starvation and disease. Critics argue that the scale of civilian casualties and displacement in Gaza resembles, in effect if not intent, some of the mechanisms of genocide.
Legal Accusations: South Africa's case against Israel at the ICJ, where they accuse Israel of genocide, mirrors the international legal scrutiny faced by Nazi officials post-World War II. The ICC's pursuit of arrest warrants for Israeli leaders, including Netanyahu, for war crimes and crimes against humanity, also echoes the post-war trials of Nazi officials.
Denial of Intent: Just as the Nazis denied or obscured their genocidal intent with euphemisms, Israeli officials have often denied genocidal intent, framing military actions as necessary defense against Hamas. Critics argue this denial parallels Nazi tactics to hide the true nature of their actions from the public.
Did you know how bodies evaporate? These piles of flesh are the remains of five bodies. Photo from the Saqallah family massacre https://x.com/HossamShabat/status/1865988002415046774
Careful Iraq, Jordan, Lebanon, Syria, and Turkey:
When Israel is done with Palestine, they'll be coming for you.
Because God promised them your land. https://x.com/R34lB0rg/status/1865964464299811176
I wonder if Erdogan and his people know, that Israel will be coming for the southeastern part of Turkey. https://x.com/R34lB0rg/status/1865964464299811176
Israel: The core of the biblical land promise, including Jerusalem.
Palestinian Territories: The West Bank and Gaza, seen by some as part of the biblical Canaan.
Lebanon: Some parts, especially in the south, were part of Canaan.
Jordan: The eastern part of the Jordan River was not explicitly included in Genesis 15 but is part of broader interpretations of the land promise.
Syria: The Euphrates boundary would include eastern areas.
Turkey: Southeastern regions along the Euphrates.
Iraq: Western border along the Euphrates.
Abraham was born in Iraq. He moved to Canaan with his family because god had promised him the land. By the time of his grandson, Jacob, they were suffering a famine. They moved to Egypt where they lived for a few generations until a Pharaoh who did not know Joseph demanded that they pay tribute. Moses led them out of Egypt and they lived in the wilderness for 40 years until Joshua led them back to Canaan which they conquered.