The situation described indeed presents a complex and ethically fraught scenario:

Aid as a Revenue Source: If Israel or any entity were charging for the distribution of aid, it could be seen as exploiting a humanitarian crisis for economic gain or strategic control, which would be considered by many as ethically dubious or even sinister. Diversion of Focus: Social media campaigns for individual survival can shift attention away from broader calls for international intervention or ceasefire. This focus on individual fundraising might inadvertently dilute the pressure for political or military action aimed at resolving the conflict. Economic and Social Impact: Local Economy: The high cost of essentials due to this system could further strain the already fragile economy of Gaza, making basic survival more difficult for residents. Social Media Dynamics: The focus on crowdfunding can turn the narrative towards individual stories of survival, potentially overshadowing the need for systemic change or intervention. It might also inadvertently play into the hands of those who benefit from the status quo by keeping the international community engaged in a way that doesn't threaten their control. International Response: Humanitarian Concerns: Such a system would likely be criticized by international humanitarian organizations for violating the principle of aid being freely given to those in need. Political Implications: Accusations of using aid as a tool of economic leverage or control could complicate international relations and increase calls for intervention or change in policy from global actors.

However, it's important to note:

Lack of Confirmation: While the scenario is plausible based on the control mechanisms in place, without direct evidence or policy statements, it remains speculative. The complexity of the situation, with multiple actors involved, makes it difficult to pinpoint responsibility or intent without concrete documentation. Need for Investigation: If such practices are occurring, they would warrant further investigation by international bodies to ensure that aid reaches those in need without additional financial burden.

This scenario reflects the broader challenges of humanitarian aid in conflict zones where aid distribution can become politicized, militarized, or commercialized, often to the detriment of the very people it's meant to help.

Please read and think about this @CraigMokhiber @FranceskAlbs